We completed 18 ADU feasibility studies in September: seven in Somerville, four in Medford, two in Boston, and one each in Arlington, Billerica, North Reading, Brockton, and Saugus. This recap covers twelve of them in detail, and every one of those twelve was rated between 7 and 9 out of 10.
Nine of the twelve started with a structure that was already there: a garage, a barn, an attic, or a room over a garage. They split into two groups with very different budgets. Space that was already framed or finished became an ADU for well under $200,000. A one-story city garage with a new second story on top cost about as much as building new.
The month in numbers
18 studies in 8 communities, with 12 covered in detail here
Of the twelve: 9 conversions of existing structures, 2 attached additions, and 1 new detached unit
Construction budgets from $75,000 to more than $300,000
Feasibility ratings from 7 to 9 out of 10
Projected rents from $1,800 a month for a one-bedroom in Brockton to $3,900 for a two-bedroom in Somerville
What we learned
Space that already exists is the bargain. In Arlington, the second floor of a detached garage was already insulated, finished, and at code height. Adding a bathroom, a kitchenette, utilities, and fire separation makes it a studio for $75,000 to $140,000 in construction, plus $10,000 to $25,000 in soft costs. In Billerica, unfinished space over an attached garage becomes a one-bedroom unit of about 875 square feet for $125,000 to $171,000. In North Reading, the framed second floor of a detached garage becomes a one-bedroom for $127,000 to $195,000 before septic. In Brockton, a finished attic with a new dormer becomes a one-bedroom for $100,000 to $150,000.
Building up on a city garage is close to new construction. Four studies in Somerville and Medford kept an old masonry garage as the first floor and added a framed second story. The units ranged from about 400 to 680 square feet, and the budgets ran from $190,000 to $340,000. For comparison, the two attached additions we studied this month, at about 700 and 750 square feet, were budgeted at roughly $237,000 to $330,000.
Four things drive that garage number.
The slab and footings. One study noted that foundation remediation can add $25,000 to $35,000. Another carried full slab replacement, and a third flagged a cracked slab and probable underpinning.
Walls on the lot line. A garage built at or near the property line needs fire-rated walls with no windows on those sides, on both levels. Every window, door, and patio has to face your own lot.
A separate electric service. In Somerville the utility requires a detached ADU to have its own service and meter. In one study that meant a 136-foot underground run across the street, with an allowance of $8,000 to $15,000 for the street crossing alone.
Sprinklers. Two of the four budgets carried a residential sprinkler system for the new unit, at roughly $15,000 to $22,000 with design.
The rents are why owners still do it. The Somerville two-bedroom units were projected at $2,600 to $3,900 a month.
On septic, one bedroom can change the project. In North Reading, the ADU's bedroom added to the house's five makes the property a six-bedroom system under Title 5, the state septic code. Depending on what the existing system turns out to be, the cost runs from $8,000 to $15,000 for a tank change to $35,000 to $70,000 or more for a full upgrade.
An old outbuilding needs an engineer before a designer. In Medford, a barn with no proper foundation could be renovated or would have to be rebuilt. A structural engineer's opinion, at about $1,000 to $2,500, decides which, and the answer moves the budget from $220,000 to as much as $350,000.
Study by study
Arlington. Studio of about 361 square feet in finished space over a detached garage. Rated 9, with a 5 to 7 month timeline.
Billerica. One-bedroom of about 875 square feet over an attached garage. $125,000 to $171,000. Rated 9.
North Reading. One-bedroom of about 667 square feet on the second floor of a detached garage, for a family member first. Rated 9, with septic as the open item.
Brockton. Attic one-bedroom of about 690 square feet with a new dormer. $100,000 to $150,000. Rated 7.
Somerville. Two-bedroom of about 600 square feet built up from a block garage behind a three-family. $250,000 to $300,000 in construction. Rated 9.
Somerville. Two-bedroom of about 600 square feet built up from a block garage behind a two-family. $250,000 to $325,000. Rated 9.
Somerville. Two-bedroom of about 680 square feet built up from a lot-line garage behind a three-family. $265,000 to $340,000. Rated 8.
Medford. Compact unit of about 400 square feet built up from a masonry garage behind a two-family. $190,000 to $250,000. Rated 8.
Medford. Barn conversion or rebuild behind a single-family home, as a studio or a unit of up to about 900 square feet. $220,000 to $350,000. Rated 8.
Medford. Two-level rear addition of about 700 square feet on a single-family home. About $237,000 to $328,000. Rated 8.
Somerville. Two-story rear addition of about 750 square feet on a two-family. $250,000 to $300,000 in construction. Rated 8.
Dorchester (Boston). New detached two-bedroom of about 810 square feet. $250,000 to $350,000. Rated 7, because a detached ADU in Boston still needs zoning board relief.
Common threads
Sprinklers are still tracking the unit count. Across the 26 studies reviewed in detail through September, out of 33 completed, sprinklers were required or likely in seven. Six of those seven were on lots that already had two or more units. A detached ADU keeps the main building from being pulled into a whole-building system, but in Somerville the new unit itself is often sprinklered.
Get the structural answer before the drawings. Three of the four second-story garage studies, and the barn study, made the same first recommendation: pay for a structural review of the existing walls, slab, and footings before spending on design. It is the least expensive step and it sets the largest part of the budget.
The state loan program fits about half of what we see. Eleven of those 26 studies were on two-family, three-family, or four-unit lots, where the MassHousing ADU Loan Program was not expected to apply. Among the single-family owners who do fit it, the limit that came up most for recent buyers was the program's 95 percent combined loan-to-value cap.
Boston detached ADUs take longer. Three of those 26 studies were in Boston. Both detached units needed their zoning route confirmed or zoning board relief. The Dorchester study estimated 13 to 22 months to occupancy, with the hearing as the largest schedule variable.
What this means for your property
If part of your building is already framed or finished, start there. Confirm that any earlier build-out was permitted.
Do not assume a garage conversion is the cheap option. If it needs a second story, a new slab, or rated lot-line walls, compare it against building new.
Hire the engineer first. A structural letter costs far less than redesigning after a surprise.
On a septic lot, order a Title 5 inspection and pull the Board of Health records before paying for drawings.
Find out what your property can support
A feasibility study answers these questions for your lot: what you can build, what it is likely to cost, what it could rent for, and what to confirm with your city or town first. Your MA ADU is an approved Feasibility Study Provider under the MHP ADU Incentive Program. Request a study at yourmaadu.com.
Figures are preliminary planning ranges drawn from feasibility studies completed from July through September 2026. They are not a quote, an appraisal, or legal or financial advice. Property details have been generalized to protect homeowner privacy.