August ADU Studies: The Same Idea Scored a 9 in One House and a 3 in Another

We completed ten ADU feasibility studies in August: four in Malden and one each in Medford, Salem, Newton, Arlington, Haverhill, and the Roslindale neighborhood of Boston. This recap covers nine of them in detail. Among those nine, the ratings ran from 2 to 9 out of 10, the widest spread of any month so far.

The pattern behind that spread is simple. Converting existing space inside a single-family home was the least expensive kind of ADU we studied. The same idea in a two-family or a four-unit building scored lowest, because adding a unit inside a multifamily building changes how the building code treats the whole structure.

The month in numbers

  • 10 studies in 7 communities, with 9 covered in detail here

  • Of the nine: 6 interior conversions (basement, attic, or existing living space), 2 new detached units, and 1 garage conversion

  • All-in budgets from $100,000 to $450,000

  • Five studies rated 7 to 9, one rated feasible with conditions, and three rated 2 to 4

What we learned

Inside a single-family home, existing space is the cheapest ADU. In Arlington, a walkout basement with its own grade-level door and about 7.5 feet of clear height supports a studio of about 340 square feet for $100,000 to $150,000, in roughly 5 to 7 months. In Roslindale, a basement of about 630 square feet that was already largely finished, with ceilings over 7 feet and a rear walkout door, came in at the same $100,000 to $150,000. In Newton, an attic unit of about 500 square feet carried $150,000 to $225,000 in construction cost, most of it for two dormers and an exterior stair.

Inside a two-family, the same project is a different project. A basement ADU in a Medford two-family makes the building a three-unit building. That brings a sprinkler system, estimated at $12,000 to $25,000, and egress openings cut through an old stone and concrete foundation. Roughly $40,000 to $75,000 of the budget was code-driven work that adds no rentable area, and the simple payback was 10 to 15 years. It was rated 3 out of 10. A similar basement in a Malden two-family carried a sprinkler estimate of $15,000 to $40,000 or more and a payback of roughly 9 to 14 years, and was rated 4.

At five units, the thresholds stack up. A study of a four-unit building in Malden looked at creating a fifth unit from existing living space. Zoning was not the obstacle. The fifth unit raised whole-building sprinkler exposure, an accessibility trigger tied to the cost of the work, and a permanent move out of one-to-four-family residential lending. The directional budget was $250,000 to $450,000 before accessibility costs, and the rating was 2.

A detached unit keeps the main building out of it. On another Malden two-family lot, a new detached two-bedroom unit of about 780 square feet was rated 8 at $250,000 to $300,000. In Salem, a detached garage that already had a finished, heated studio with a bath and a drain line to the house can become a legal one-bedroom unit for $117,000 to $130,000, or $132,000 to $150,000 if the fire department requires sprinklers.

Local dimensional rules still decide the design. In Haverhill, a garage with an apartment above it was rated 9, with one point held for a 20-foot height cap on accessory buildings. A two-story garage with a unit above typically reaches 22 to 26 feet. In Newton, the lot was too small for a two-family conversion without a discretionary special permit, which the study estimated would add 6 to 12 months and $15,000 to $40,000 in soft costs. The attic ADU is by right.

Study by study

  • Arlington. Walkout basement studio of about 340 square feet in a single-family home. $100,000 to $150,000. Rated 9.

  • Roslindale (Boston). Basement one-bedroom of about 630 square feet in a single-family home, allowed with a building permit under Boston's rules for internal ADUs. $100,000 to $150,000. Rated 9.

  • Haverhill. New detached two-car garage with a one-bedroom unit of 500 to 600 square feet above, intended for below-market rental. About $207,000 to $269,000 with soft costs. Rated 9.

  • Malden. New detached two-bedroom unit of about 780 square feet behind a two-family. $250,000 to $300,000. Rated 8.

  • Newton. Attic studio or one-bedroom of about 500 square feet for an owner planning to age in place. $150,000 to $225,000 in construction. Rated 7.

  • Salem. Conversion of an already finished and plumbed detached garage to a one-bedroom unit of about 450 square feet. $117,000 to $150,000 depending on sprinklers. Feasible with conditions.

  • Malden. Basement one-bedroom in a two-family on a steep lot. $170,000 to $245,000. Rated 4 and not currently recommended.

  • Medford. Basement one-bedroom in a two-family. $160,000 to $235,000, plus $30,000 to $60,000 if the floor has to be lowered. Rated 3.

  • Malden. A fifth unit inside a four-unit building. $250,000 to $450,000 as a directional figure. Rated 2.

Common threads

Sprinklers followed the unit count. Across the 14 studies reviewed in detail through August, out of 15 completed, sprinklers were required or likely in four. All four were on lots that already had two or more units. None of the eight single-family studies flagged sprinklers as required or likely. If you own a two-family and are thinking about a basement or attic unit, the sprinkler answer is the first thing to get, in writing, from the building and fire departments.

Ceiling height comes before everything else in a basement. Four of this month's studies were basement units. In the two that scored 9, the height was already known to work. In the two that scored 3 and 4, it had not been measured, and one carried a dig-out contingency of $30,000 to $60,000. Measure to the joists and to the lowest pipe, duct, or beam before paying for design.

Financing favors the single-family owner. The MassHousing ADU Loan Program is aimed at owner-occupied single-family homes. Six of those 14 studies were on lots with two or more units, where the program was not expected to apply. Those owners were looking at home equity, cash-out refinancing, or renovation loans at market rates.

Boston treats interior and detached ADUs differently. Two of those 14 studies were in Boston. The interior basement unit in Roslindale needs only a building permit. The detached unit in last month's East Boston study needs its permitting route confirmed and may need zoning relief.

What this means for your property

  1. Count your units first. A single-family home adding one ADU stays a one- or two-family dwelling under the building code. A two-family adding a unit inside the building does not.

  2. If you own a two-family, look at the yard or the garage. A detached unit can avoid the code changes that an interior unit triggers.

  3. Measure your basement or attic before you call a designer. Height and a second way out decide whether the space can be a legal unit.

  4. Ask how your town measures the height of an accessory building before designing a garage with a unit above.

Find out what your property can support

A feasibility study answers these questions for your lot: what you can build, what it is likely to cost, what it could rent for, and what to confirm with your city or town first. Your MA ADU is an approved Feasibility Study Provider under the MHP ADU Incentive Program. Request a study at yourmaadu.com.

Figures are preliminary planning ranges drawn from feasibility studies completed in July and August 2026. They are not a quote, an appraisal, or legal or financial advice. Property details have been generalized to protect homeowner privacy.

Previous
Previous

September ADU Studies: Eighteen Studies and the Real Cost of Converting a Garage

Next
Next

July ADU Studies: Five Properties, Five Communities, and Why 900 Square Feet Is Not Always the Limit